TagMortgage penalties

Posted January 25, 20121 Comment Interest rates

BMO 2.99% No Frills mortgage needs another look.

It’s January 25, 2012… that’s the original deadline date issued by BMO for their NO FRILLs 2.99% 5 year fixed rate mortgage. Since announcing that 2.99% rate, BMO has reportedly been flooded with calls and applications. And rightfully so. That’s the lowest advertised 5 yr fixed rate in history. (we need to say thank you to BMO… they woke up the competition and the competition answered.. we have seen competitive offers from the non-bank lenders… no restrictions or limitations… This is great news for the consumer.)

This product has also drawn some criticism…There was an interesting articles asking if this product was too good to be true…. click here to see what The Toronto Star thinks.

Let’s look at the restrictions and limitations more closely… If you are 100% certain about the next 5 years in your life, your job, your health, your family’s health, then this may be a great product for you…. But if you look at the stats, we, as Canadians, on average refinance or change mortgages every 3 years… With that in mind, the product can be very costly for the unsuspecting borrower….read on and I’ll explain…

I’m not too concerned with the limited prepayment privileges. The biggest potential risk to borrowers is the inability to refinance outside BMO should they experience some financial problems in the next 5 years. If a borrower runs into financial problems and needs to take the mortgage elsewhere, because they won’t qualify for a BMO refinance, they can’t do it. The mortgage can only be paid out if the house is sold…

An an even bigger problem is the BIG SIX penalty calculation…. let’s say you can somehow refinance in 2 or 3 years with BMO, or you do sell the house and are not porting the mortgage… well, now you must deal with a penalty calculation that makes you pay for the original discount you received at the time of the original mortgage…. And LOOK OUT…This is where we have seen penalties of 6, 9, 12, 14 and even 16 months worth of interest being charged by the Banks to get out of a mortgage..(click here to see how banks calculate their penalties). (hey, Federal Government, didn’t you promise to standardize mortgage penalty calculation 2 years ago??… when is that going to happen?))

And if you need more money added to your mortgage, what assurance will you have that BMO or any other BIG SIX bank, will give you a good rate or a discount on those new monies? None… they certainly won’t have to, given your penalty to exit would be higher than other non-bank lenders… This subject is not talked about very much by the media or by the banks… We will be commenting on this further in future posts…. (hey, how about CIBC and that class action lawsuit over mortgage penalty charges??… I’ll be making some comments on this soon).

Here’s some advice… seek out Lenders that have better penalty calculations... they are out there… they just aren’t as obvious as the Big Six Banks… talk to a mortgage broker and get some comparisons… you might be surprised to know that competitive rates exist without having to give up your future options…

Posted March 23, 201119 Comments Case study

CBC news reports Scotiabank slams client with $30,000 penalty!

A word about world events the past 4 weeks… We have seen a lot of turmoil overseas…… Egypt, Libya and other middle east countries…. We need to pay attention…. Let’s hope for an immediate and peaceful resolution…

The Tsunami in Japan has been horrible… the images on TV are tough to watch…what a tragedy… Our hearts go out to the people of that nation.

Fixed rates drop slightly and Variable rates remain flat.

We have also seen how mortgage rates can be affected by these events… The uncertainty has caused the Bond market to fall…. and we even saw a very small rate reduction by the Big Banks… Posted Fixed rates are down around 10bps… 5 yr fixed is 5.34%. Continue reading “CBC news reports Scotiabank slams client with $30,000 penalty!”

Posted February 24, 2011 Mortgage News

TD and RBC CEO’s income $11million each for 2010…

Are the BIG SIX Bank CEO’s that good?

It’s that time of the year again… when Bank CEO salaries have to be reported… TD’s CEO Ed Clark earned $11.3million on profits of $4.6billion in 2010, RBC’s CEO Gord Nixon pocketed $11million. Congratulations….! Staggering numbers considering that we are just coming out of (hopefully) the worst recession ever… click here for more on Bank salaries.

So what’s the problem?

There has been so much publicity about how strong our Canadian Banking system has been through this recession…. And yes, it’s true.. we have held it together very well. But was it that our Bankers were that smart or just that far behind the times??

It has been said that Canada is always 5 years behind the U.S. Ever heard that saying? Well, it’s true for many things, including Banking and Financial Services… In 2006, we saw the introduction of 30, 35 and then 40 year amortization mortgages. We also saw $0 money down mortgages….. Interest only mortgages!! 107% loan to value financing!!!

These products were beginning to gain some popularity in Canada.. but then in October 2008, the U.S. mortgage crisis hit… and all the new products were pulled from the shelf. Imagine if these products were introduced to Canada 5 years earlier…. Imagine how many of us would have been affected…. Don’t be fooled into believing that it was our Banking system that saved us…

Look, the plain truth is that we got lucky… we were a bit slow to embrace these products… and that’s really our infamous Canadian conservatism coming out… It’s got nothing to do with our Bankers being that much smarter… It’s got everything to do with you, the general public, the average Canadian, not taking to change quickly…. This is the real reason we didn’t suffer a worse fate.

How much did mortgage penalties contribute to Bank Profits?

Here’s a bit of math to play with…. Statistics tell us that on average, Canadians move or refinance their mortgage every three years…. The stats also tell us that approximately 75% of all mortgages are in a fixed rate term… I would venture to guess that probably 95% of those are in a 5 year fixed rate…. Okay, so now let’s look what the average penalty would cost you to break your mortgage…

And today, I have another example that I will share with you… it’s about a young couple that needed some help…. (I get these almost daily, by the way)….

A $250k mortgage with a 5.15% rate with 28 months til maturity… The penalty quote to break the mortgage was $11k... I gave some advice and helped to get it down to $8k... That penalty still works out to over 7 months interest. Can you say ka-ching!! The Banks have made an absolute fortune on the backs of unsuspecting Canadians….

The Govt and the Banks should tighten credit card rules

Last November, the Banks pressured the Federal Govt to tighten mortgage lending, to make it harder to take a Variable Rate Mortgage… to make it harder to refinance your debts into a mortgage…. The results are bad for Canadians.. we now have to take a 5 year fixed rate mortgage in many cases… we now have to keep our higher interest credit card debt, loans, and other debt…. Canadians are being forced to keep these higher interest debts while Banks increase their profit margins… Here’s a great article about Household Debt..

By the way, there are no rules for giving out a credit card…

Posted January 4, 201188 Comments Case study

Mortgage Penalties exposed…. an in-depth study reveals unjust penalties.

On November 26, 2010, we reported that a good source told us the govt would not follow through on their promise to standardize mortgage penalties until this spring, at the earliest.

On December 15, 2010, we also reported that discounted Fixed mortgage rates were going up but Posted mortgage rates were staying the same… we stated that your mortgage penalty would not decrease as it normally does when rates go up.

We received some inquires about this article. Questions like ‘shouldn’t my penalty go down if rates are going up?’ and ‘how could a mortgage penalty be more expensive if the Bank’s didn’t increase their posted rate?’

Okay, here’s my shocker statements…. A $200,000 mortgage taken in December 2008 will cost you $16,800 to get out of today…. but 12 years ago it would have cost you approximately $8,340 and even today, it should only cost $11,640. Got your attention? Please read the entire report to better understand. Continue reading “Mortgage Penalties exposed…. an in-depth study reveals unjust penalties.”

Posted December 15, 20101 Comment Mortgage Rates

Higher Bond yields are bringing higher fixed rates..but that’s not all.

Some of Canada’s major banks have raised their 5 year fixed mortgage rates… but not their posted rates. It’s become common practice for the Big Six Retail banks to show a posted 5 year fixed rate ….but in the past few years the Banks have also started to advertise their so-called ‘special’ rate.

The ‘special’ rate has increased by 0.25% to 4.19% to 4.29%, depending on which Bank you visit. Of course, these rates are still much higher than the true discounted rates available through Mortgage Brokers. Wholesale 5 year fixed rates are still around 3.69% to 3.79% (these will probably go up in a few days by 0.25%). But this is nothing new.

What’s different this time is that the Posted Rates didn’t go up. We’re not sure why, but here is one definite result of this move…your mortgage prepayment penalty will not decrease, which is the usual effect of an interest rate hike. That’s right, if you have a closed fixed rate mortgage to payout, your penalty is either 3 months interest or Interest Rate Differential (IRD).

IRD is calculated many different ways now and we are hoping the Federal Govt’s announcement of a standardized prepayment penalty will come soon (we hear it could come this spring). Currently, Banks use formulas that include the Posted rate to calculate your penalty. This calculation has become a lucrative source of revenue for the Banks. Reports of 6, 10 and even 14 months worth of interest have been charged to unsuspecting borrowers. Record low rates means record HIGH penalties. Come on Federal Govt, we need this change now.

As an aside, Variable rates are still around 2.25%…. this larger gap between fixed and variable is going to make Variable more attractive.